Which remaining playoff QB would you rather have leading your team?

[Oliver Klosov]

Jake Delhomme, Panthers

Jake Plummer, Broncos

Matt Hasselbeck, Seahawks

Ben Roethlisberger, Steelers

[mpt0069]

I voted Jake Delhomme. 5-1 playoff record with a 108 or something like that playoff QB rating.

[Oliver Klosov]

I voted Jake Delhomme. 5-1 playoff record with a 108 or something like that playoff QB rating.

highest ever playoff QB rating, including Joe Montana.

Of course Montana has 4 rings.... but of the QB's left Delhomme has the most experience.

I asked this because I thought it was a no brainer - but on around the horn 2 guys took Roethlisberger and one took Delhomme and one took Plummer.

[Bishop]

Hasselbeck of course.

Both Hasselbeck and Delhomme are having fantastic seasons, but Hasselbeck is better across the board. Granted, Delhomme as experience in the NFC championship game and the Super Bowl, but minus DeShaun Foster and doubling up on Steve Smith....what does that leave Delhomme? Hasselbeck's got Ingram and Jackson back, Alexander is playing and will contribute, Jeramy Stevens has blown up this season, and J.J. having a fantastic season and is slotted at #3.

For Delhomme, Kerry Colbert hasn't even shown up this season, which is a shame

[cottonzway]

I picked the defence option. Each of the QBs up there have tendencies to have "Kerry Collins" moments. Not bad QBs, but none of them have a ring so I'll take the best defence to win.

[Oliver Klosov]

Hasselbeck of course.

Both Hasselbeck and Delhomme are having fantastic seasons, but Hasselbeck is better across the board. Granted, Delhomme as experience in the NFC championship game and the Super Bowl, but minus DeShaun Foster and doubling up on Steve Smith....what does that leave Delhomme? Hasselbeck's got Ingram and Jackson back, Alexander is playing and will contribute, Jeramy Stevens has blown up this season, and J.J. having a fantastic season and is slotted at #3.

For Delhomme, Kerry Colbert hasn't even shown up this season, which is a shame

"We want the ball, and we're gonna score"

[Bishop]

"We want the ball, and we're gonna score"
that, plus last year's goalline pass

2 wrongs make a right....Seattle's going to the Super Bowl this year, nigguh

[mpt0069]

"We want the ball, and we're gonna score"

Classic television.

[Bird]

defesne wins championships, the ravens won with dilfer for christs sake

[Bishop]

how dare you talk down on the Dilf

[Oliver Klosov]

defesne wins championships, the ravens won with dilfer for christs sake

don't cross the dilf. You're flirting with negs.

[Bishop]

*itchy neg finger*

may this be a warning, slap on the wrist, 30 public lashings, and a finger in the eye there Dook

[cottonzway]

Can you two explain the Trent Dilfer bandwagon? Just curious.

[Oliver Klosov]

Can you two explain the Trent Dilfer bandwagon? Just curious.

can you explain why to NOT have one?

[cottonzway]

can you explain why to NOT have one?

http://www.nfl.com/players/playerpage/1065

107 TDs 116 INTs 71.3 QB rating

Again I'm curious

[Oliver Klosov]

http://www.nfl.com/players/playerpage/1065

107 TDs 116 INTs 71.3 QB rating

Again I'm curious

The Dilf has his finger on the neg button


http://www.cnnsi.com/your_turn/news/2001/01/23/chatreel_kirwan/t1_dilfer_ap.jpg

[cottonzway]

The Dilf has his finger on the neg button


http://www.cnnsi.com/your_turn/news/2001/01/23/chatreel_kirwan/t1_dilfer_ap.jpg

Maybe so but it still didn't answer my question. The guy isn't awful, but it's not like he is heading to Canton either.

[Oliver Klosov]

Maybe so but it still didn't answer my question. The guy isn't awful, but it's not like he is heading to Canton either.

1. Are you saying The Dilf isn't Hall of Fame worthy?
2. You think only Hall of Famers ge tbandwagons?
3. The Dilf pwns. Deal with it.

[Oliver Klosov]

Honestly though, the only one that compares to The Dilf is The Housh.


Imagine if The Dilf and The Housh were teammates?

[Malibu]

Can you two explain the Trent Dilfer bandwagon? Just curious.


Trent Dilfer's Super Bowl rings-1

Dan Marino's Super Bowl rings-0

[Bishop]

teh Dilf orchestrated one of the greatest offensive machines to win the Super Bowl....but noooooooooooooo, Ray Ray and the D got all the credit

[Bev]

Plummer. Bitches.

[Oliver Klosov]

Plummer. Bitches.

The only reason I'll allow this is because he is rocking a tremendously sweet beard.

[cottonzway]

2000 12 TDs 11 INTs in the SB year


Those are the numbers.

[Bev]

2000 12 TDs 11 INTs in the SB year


Those are the numbers.

And a MIGHTY impressive win streak. You're playing with fire here.

[Bishop]

12 TD's and 11 Int's

do Super Bowl QB's always have to have outstanding numbers? Look at Peyton....I rest my case

[cottonzway]

The only reason I'll allow this is because he is rocking a tremendously sweet beard.

That plus this:

http://www.geekchik.com/images/jakebird.jpg

[Malibu]

2000 12 TDs 11 INTs in the SB year


Those are the numbers.


True, BUT

Trent Dilfer's Super Bowl rings-1

Dan Marino's Super Bowl rings-0


These numbers matter more.

[Oliver Klosov]

2000 12 TDs 11 INTs in the SB year


Those are the numbers.

The following are the career numbers of a hall of fame QB with 1 super bowl ring :


G Com Att Pct. Yds. y/a TD INT
140 1886 3762 50.1 27663 7.4 173 220

[Bishop]

Just like in the NBA

Bill Wennington >>>>>>> Karl Malone, John Stockton, Charles Barkley, Patrick Ewing

[cottonzway]

Just like in the NBA

Bill Wennington >>>>>>> Karl Malone, John Stockton, Charles Barkley, Patrick Ewing

Posts like that make you lose credability man. Really flawed logic there.

The team Bill Wennington played on >>>>> Karl Malone, John Stockton, Charles Barkley, and Patrick Ewing.

[DeltaSigChi4]

Jim Kelly.

E

[Bishop]

Posts like that make you lose credability man. Really flawed logic there.

The team Bill Wennington played on >>>>> Karl Malone, John Stockton, Charles Barkley, and Patrick Ewing.
the team? well, if you're going to say it that way, then you need to give more credit to the "3 headed monster" instead of the team in whole

[cottonzway]

the team? well, if you're going to say it that way, then you need to give more credit to the "3 headed monster" instead of the team in whole

3 headed monster included obviously.

[Bishop]

oh nonono, just the 3 headed monster

[cottonzway]

http://www.superbowl.com/history/boxscores

Just look at the others who won the SB. It was either a great QB or a team known to have a great defence.

[Bishop]

Mark Rypien and the Redskins had a great defense?

[Bev]

Mark Rypien and the Redskins had a great defense?

ZZZZZZZZING!!

Seriously, though. Rypien threw the greatest deep ball of any 80s QB. Like the Jeff George of the 80s.

[cottonzway]

Mark Rypien and the Redskins had a great defense?

You're reaching back 16 years there. :D If you have reach back 16 years that should tell you something. The Skins had a good defence that year. Not domminate, but good. They also had an outstanding O-line. It's not so hard when you have these 5 guys blocking for you:

Bostic, Jeff C
McKenzie, Raleigh G
Schlereth, Mark G
Jacoby, Joe T
Lachey, Jim T

[Oliver Klosov]

ZZZZZZZZING!!

Seriously, though. Rypien threw the greatest deep ball of any 80s QB. Like the Jeff George of the 80s.

Jeff Blake throws the best deep ball.

[Bev]

Jeff Blake throws the best deep ball.

I should amend that to "QBs that actually get playing time. My bad."

[Bishop]

yeah yeah, the Hogs....but you said It was either a great QB or a team known to have a great defence. the only thing I remember from that year is whatever Rypien threw up, Monk and Clark were there to catch it

the 98-99 Vikings remind me of that team: Cunningham tossed it up and Moss and Carter were there to snag it no matter where it was thrown....fun year for the NFL

[cottonzway]

Jay Schrader probably had the best deep ball arm ever, but just couldn't hit an open target. The guy could throw the ball like 85 yards in the air.

[cottonzway]

yeah yeah, the Hogs....but you said It was either a great QB or a team known to have a great defence. the only thing I remember from that year is whatever Rypien threw up, Monk and Clark were there to catch it

the 98-99 Vikings remind me of that team: Cunningham tossed it up and Moss and Carter were there to snag it no matter where it was thrown....fun year for the NFL

Well you were able to find one catch from 16 years ago then. Congrats. ;) Still had to reach back a long time ago because it is not the norm at all. They even kind of go in their own catagory because of that line, but correct in terms of not being a great QB or great defence.

[Bishop]

hey, you posted the link, not I

[J. Walter Weatherman]

Roethlisberger

Why? Cool name.

[Sir Gibbs]

I went for defense is what counts, but i'd go for hasselbeck if D-FENCE wasn't an option

[my sex is artsy]

Can we make "Not Plummer and Not Hasselbeck" an option?

[DaTechnician29]

Not bad QBs, but none of them have a ring

That'll change this year

[Bird]

fuck that dilf sucks


{turtles up in fetal position, waiting to be negged for what appears as blasphemous to some}